Skip to content
aatam
Choose a time
Menu
An illustrated worldThe village council

A question for life · Decision Making

What would it mean to you if they disagreed with your decision?

Explore this question

A question preview · At your pace

Checking your interest…

Recognise the moment

What’s at stake?

You lead a team choosing a supplier today. Both proposals meet the brief. You favour the smaller firm; most colleagues favour the familiar one. Everyone has been heard. The booking expires this afternoon, and your closest colleague asks for another discussion.

A decision starts the work and disappoints someone. Another round may cost the booking and confidence in your leadership.

Explore a possible response

What it offers

Act on the fit you judge strongest and begin work.

What it asks of you

Colleagues may withhold support if the unfamiliar choice struggles.

What it offers

Give divided colleagues another chance to agree.

What it asks of you

The booking may go elsewhere while responsibility remains yours.

What it offers

Begin with the support most of the team already offers.

What it asks of you

Give up the stronger fit you saw; the minority may feel dismissed.

Every path carries a trade-off. Consider what matters to you and the people involved.

An expectation to explore

What might your mind be protecting?

A possible reading to explore. It may not describe your response.

If I decide while they disagree, I could lose their support.

Another round of agreement can make an owned decision feel less isolating.

01 · Your peace

The unresolved call keeps returning to mind, even after the useful discussion is over.

02 · Decision Making

Leading a timely decision gives way to collecting reassurance.

A question to sit with

Do you need new information, or agreement before you can let yourself decide?

Decision Making · In practice

Make a decision without needing everyone to agree.

If getting the work started is your priority, making the call can move preparations forward while accepting that valued colleagues may disagree.

Your response can serve you here. Another choice has costs too.

A possibility to consider.

If your priority is timely leadership, return to the same council and two households. Rehearse naming your decision and its reason. The other elder can remain disappointed; the practice is carrying the decision without demanding their approval.

Choose whether this practice fits what you want to explore. Keeping your first response is valid.

If a small step would help.

One possible example, only if it fits your chosen response and circumstances:

Choose one small, reversible decision that is yours to make. Hear the necessary input, name your choice and allow a different view.

Keeping your response or taking no action is equally valid.
Explore programme depth
The story behind this moment

Set in the village council

Enter the village council.

You enter the council chamber as the trusted advisor standing in for its absent head. Today you must choose which of two households will host the harvest feast. Both have hosted well before. One elder has gathered most of the room behind his household; the other has asked you to consider theirs. The council has given you the final say. The elder sets down his cup.

One household will leave disappointed. We have all had our say. Where will we gather?

  1. Choose the household you judge best

    What it offers
    Preparations can begin on the decision you believe serves the feast.
    The trade-off
    The other family may withdraw its support for you.

  2. Stay until the council agrees

    What it offers
    Keep working toward a decision the council can share.
    The trade-off
    They may ask someone else to make the decision.

  3. Back the household with most supporters

    What it offers
    Give the feast a shared start.
    The trade-off
    The other family may accuse you of dismissing them.
Explore the paths 1 of 3

Notice the pull. Afterwards, explore what it means in your life.

Research behind this moment

The research behind the concepts. AATAM brings them into this moment through its own framework.

AATAM Research and the evidence

Find your way into this moment.

Checking the latest showing…

More questions in work

Explore the sequence 1 of 3